What is PCC? Framing scoping review questions,explained through PICO
This article is for anyone who set out on a scoping review, asked, “So do we frame the question with PICO?”, was told, “No—use PCC,” and walked away confused. PCC is the question framework for scoping reviews. It's a relative of PICO, but the resemblance is only skin-deep; the philosophy underneath is quite different. Here's what PCC means, how it differs from PICO, and how to actually build one—written for beginners.
Published: 2026-07-22
Hear a paper before you read it
No PDF or sign-up needed. Start by listening to a sample.
The three elements of PCC
PCC stands for three elements.
P (Population/Participants): whose research are you collecting? C (Concept): what is the research about—the intervention, phenomenon, or method at the center. C (Context): in what setting, region, or situation?
For example: “Research on telerehabilitation (Concept) for older adults (Population) in home-care settings (Context)”—that sentence is the shape of a scoping review question.
The biggest difference from PICO: no Comparison
Line PCC up against PICO and you'll notice the missing C for Comparison. That's no accident.
PICO is a framework for answering a question—“Is intervention A more effective than comparator B?” PCC is a framework for mapping—“What research exists in this area?” There's no comparison because the review isn't judging which option wins. That's where the two philosophies part ways.
Listen to why we use PCC on the paper radio
As a related paper, we introduce how to choose a method that fits the purpose of your review. This is a methodological explanation for thinking about question formulation using PCC, and is not a study that conducted a scoping review or a trial of treatment efficacy.
No PDF or sign-up needed. Two voices · 2:55
Systematic review or scoping review: how do you choose?
Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach
Munn Z, Peters MDJ, Stern C, Tufanaru C, McArthur A, Aromataris E. BMC Medical Research Methodology. 2018;18:143. DOI: 10.1186/s12874-018-0611-x
Copyright 2018 The Author(s). Original paper · CC BY 4.0
Paperfy uses AI to abridge and translate the original paper into audio. These are not the authors’ voices. Summaries and translations may contain errors; check important information in the original. Not a substitute for the paper or medical advice.
This is an abbreviated version based on the method selection, Discussion, and Conclusion of the original paper. It is a 2018 methodological explanation and is not a substitute for the latest manuals. This is not a paper that verified treatment efficacy, AI effectiveness, or automatic selection by PCC.
Listening to this sample does not use your one-PDF trial.
Which to use depends on the shape of your question
You can tell whether your review calls for PICO or PCC by phrasing it as a question.
If you want to know “Does it work?” or “Which is better?”, that's PICO—systematic review territory. If you want to know “What has been studied, and how much?” or “What methods are in use?”, that's PCC—scoping review territory. If the shape of the question and the type of review don't match, you will get stuck midway—guaranteed. When in doubt, check with your supervisor at this stage.
The hardest part is pinning down the Concept
Of the three PCC elements, beginners most often stall on Concept. Population and Context are relatively easy to define concretely; Concept tends to come out either too broad or too narrow.
The trick is to draw the boundary between research that belongs on your map and research that doesn't. Take “telerehabilitation”: does it include instruction over video calls? App-guided self-training? Spelling out that boundary in advance dramatically reduces the churn during screening later.
From PCC to search terms and selection criteria
Once the PCC is settled, both the search and the selection criteria fall out of it.
Search terms come from combining synonyms for the Population, Concept, and Context. Selection criteria start from the principle “include studies matching all PCC elements,” with added conditions for year, language, and study type. PCC is both the frame for your question and the blueprint for the entire review.
Getting through the screening pile faster
Because a scoping review deliberately collects broadly, the reference count balloons. Screening hundreds of papers takes time, and the barrier is often simply getting started on each PDF.
Paperfy turns each research paper into a roughly 3-minute radio show—a host and guest talking through the background, methods, key findings, and significance. Listen to the paper as a short radio show first, then read the PDF yourself for the details. The show starts in about 20 seconds, so you can decide whether a paper matches your PCC before committing to a full read. You can try one PDF on the landing page without creating an account.
The full process, in a separate article
Once your question is framed with PCC, the next steps are searching, charting, and identifying gaps. The whole scoping review process is covered in our guide to scoping review methods (https://paperfy.app/en/articles/scoping-review-method)—read on from there.
PCC design check
- I framed the question with the three elements: Population, Concept, Context.
- My question asks about the map, not for an answer.
- I put the Concept's boundary into words—what's in and what's out.
- I derived my search terms and selection criteria from the PCC.
Turn a paper PDF into a 3-minute radio show
No registration required. Try a paper PDF you want to read.
Systematic review
Explore This Topic
Read the full cluster for this workflow, from first steps to practical use.
Read Next
These guides continue the same workflow.