PaperfyPAPERFYHome
Start freeLog in
Paperfy Guides
AI data extraction from papersScreening5 minFor anyone extracting data for a review or meta-analysis

Data Extraction With AI:Draft by Machine, Verify Every Number in the Source

The included studies are settled, and data extraction begins. You open the first paper and start copying down whatever looks useful — and a few papers in, you notice every row covers different items. That rework is the classic data-extraction failure, and the cause is simple: data extraction isn't writing summaries — it's pulling predefined items from every paper in the same format. This article walks through the process and where AI genuinely helps.

Published: 2026-07-22

Turn a paper PDF into a 3-minute radio show

No registration required. Try a paper PDF you want to read.

Try without signing up

In this article

Design the extraction table before opening a single paperPilot it on two or three papersLet AI draft the tableVerify the numbers: units, denominators, directionNumbers destined for meta-analysis get an extra level of careRecord where every value came fromGetting oriented with Paperfy firstStart with Paperfy

Design the extraction table before opening a single paper

The first task isn't reading — it's table design. Decide the columns first.

A standard set: author, year, country, study design, participants (number and characteristics), intervention or exposure, comparison, outcome and its definition, main result (effect size and confidence interval), follow-up period, missing data, limitations. Work backward from what your review question needs, and fix the columns before opening the first paper.

Pilot it on two or three papers

Table in hand, don't launch into the full set — try it on two or three papers first. This is where ambiguous column definitions and paper-to-paper formatting differences surface.

Revising the design at this point prevents the disaster of redoing everything later. If you're working as a team, use the pilot to standardize the entry rules.

Let AI draft the table

Once the columns are fixed, AI becomes powerful. Ask it to “extract these items in this format” for each paper, and a draft extraction table appears in minutes.

Reviewing and correcting a draft feels nothing like filling blank cells by hand. AI's role is the first move that fills in the cells — not the guarantor of what's in them. Hold onto that distinction and you get both speed and accuracy.

Verify the numbers: units, denominators, direction

When reviewing the draft, three things about every number deserve special attention.

Units (percentage or count, months or years). Denominator (the ITT population, the analyzed population, or completers only). Direction (does the effect size favor the intervention group or the control group?). AI drafts slip on these three most often, and any one of these errors can flip the conclusion of your review. Always verify against the original text, its figures and tables, and the supplements when needed.

Numbers destined for meta-analysis get an extra level of care

If extracted data will feed a meta-analysis, raise the bar. Check that the effect size type, time point, and analysis population definitions correspond across studies, and note whether values were read from a figure or from the text.

Whether studies can be pooled, and how values can be converted, are statistical judgments — if in doubt, consult a statistician, your supervisor, or your team. That's territory neither AI nor this article can cover for you.

Record where every value came from

A practical habit: in each cell or row of the extraction table, note the source location — Table 2, p.6, Supplement.

Verification and team cross-checks then stop involving repeat hunts through the same paper. Across dozens of items and dozens of studies, this small habit adds up to days.

Getting oriented with Paperfy first

Before diving into extraction, Paperfy can help you get oriented. Drop a paper PDF and listen to a roughly 3-minute radio show that walks through the background, methods, key findings with concrete numbers, limitations, and significance.

Listen to the paper as a short radio show first, then open the PDF yourself in your own PDF reader for the detailed extraction work. Checking figures, tables, units, and denominators is your job in the source PDF — Paperfy is the entry point that gets you ready faster.

Key takeaways

  • The extraction table's columns were fixed before opening any paper.
  • The table and entry rules were revised after a two-to-three-paper pilot.
  • Units, denominators, and directions were verified in the original text.
  • The source (table and page number) of every value was recorded.

Turn a paper PDF into a 3-minute radio show

No registration required. Try a paper PDF you want to read.

Try without signing up

Screening

Explore This Topic

Read the full cluster for this workflow, from first steps to practical use.

Browse all guides

Read Next

These guides continue the same workflow.

risk of bias assessmentRisk of Bias Assessment: Ask About Distortion, Not Qualitysystematic review vs meta-analysisSystematic Review vs. Meta-Analysis: One Is a Process, the Other Is a Toolhow to do a scoping reviewHow to Do a Scoping Review: Draw the Map, Don't Chase the Answer